Martin Brundle Questions if Lewis Hamilton’s Best Days Are Over

Martin Brundle has reignited debates in the Formula 1 world, questioning whether Lewis Hamilton’s “absolute peak” may now be behind him as the seven-time World Champion gears up for his high-profile switch to Ferrari in 2025. Yet, Brundle insists that Hamilton’s experience and talent still make him a potent force on the F1 grid.

Hamilton’s Emotional Goodbye to Mercedes

Hamilton’s decision to trigger a release clause in his Mercedes contract last winter marked the end of an era. His final season with Mercedes proved to be an emotional rollercoaster, from the jubilation of standing on the top step at Silverstone to moments of vulnerability, such as his disheartening performance in Qatar where he admitted, “I’m definitely not fast anymore.”

Russell’s Dominance Raises Eyebrows

The 2024 season saw Hamilton face stiff competition from his younger Mercedes team-mate, George Russell, who outqualified Hamilton 19-5 over the course of the season. This performance gap has left many questioning whether Ferrari’s decision to replace Carlos Sainz with Hamilton, who will be 40 at the time of his Ferrari debut, is a gamble that could backfire.

Brundle’s Candid Take on Hamilton’s Future

Following Hamilton’s P4 finish at the Abu Dhabi finale, Brundle shared his perspective on the matter, praising Hamilton’s ability to fight through adversity while also acknowledging concerns about his age.

“Tremendous drive,” Brundle remarked. “He showed a lot of pace, a lot of determination. But is his absolute peak behind him as he turns 40 in January? It might be.”

Hamilton’s Record Still Speaks Volumes

Despite raising doubts, Brundle emphasized Hamilton’s extraordinary legacy, pointing to his record-breaking 105 Grand Prix wins, 104 pole positions, and 202 podium finishes. He also highlighted Hamilton’s ability to deliver under pressure.

“Even at 98%, Lewis Hamilton in a race-winning Ferrari can still win races,” Brundle noted. “Perhaps a change of scenery and fresh motivation will unlock something new in him.”

Ferrari’s Gamble: High Risk, High Reward?

Hamilton’s arrival at Ferrari pairs him with Charles Leclerc, one of the most aggressive and fastest drivers in Formula 1 over a single lap. The duo’s dynamic will undoubtedly create one of the most closely watched rivalries on the grid.

Yet critics, including former F1 team boss Eddie Jordan, have questioned Ferrari’s decision, with Jordan even suggesting Ferrari’s chairman John Elkann was making a reckless gamble. Nevertheless, Ferrari sees Hamilton’s experience as the missing piece in their championship puzzle.

Fresh Faces at Mercedes—A New Era Begins

Hamilton’s departure opens the door for Mercedes to embrace a new generation, with 18-year-old prodigy Kimi Antonelli set to debut in 2025 after an impressive run in Formula 2. Mercedes hopes Antonelli can rise to the occasion and continue the team’s legacy of dominance.

Can Hamilton Prove Critics Wrong?

The scrutiny surrounding Hamilton’s move to Ferrari highlights the high expectations placed upon him. As he faces questions about his age and consistency, Hamilton will need to silence doubters by delivering results early in his Ferrari tenure.

While Brundle acknowledges Hamilton may no longer be at his absolute peak, he firmly believes the Briton’s hunger for success remains intact. A competitive Ferrari could reignite Hamilton’s drive, providing a platform for him to showcase his skill and potentially add to his legacy.

The Road Ahead: Hamilton’s Ferrari Journey Begins

As the motorsport world watches closely, Hamilton’s transition to Ferrari represents more than just a career move—it’s a test of whether experience can triumph over youth in modern Formula 1. With a proven track record and the determination to defy critics, Hamilton is poised to make his mark once again.

Whether Ferrari’s gamble pays off or not, one thing is certain—2025 will be a defining year in Lewis Hamilton’s illustrious career. Fans and analysts alike are bracing for what promises to be one of the most exciting and unpredictable F1 seasons in recent memory.