Ferrari’s decision to part ways with Carlos Sainz and bring in seven-time World Champion Lewis Hamilton for the F1 2025 season has set the Formula 1 world ablaze with debate. Former F1 team owner Eddie Jordan delivered a scathing critique of Ferrari chairman John Elkann, stating he “must have rocks in his head” for making such a contentious call.
Heartbreaking Farewell for Carlos Sainz
Sainz and his father, Carlos Sr., were reportedly in tears during an emotional farewell at the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix, marking the end of the Spaniard’s tenure with Ferrari. Despite the knowledge that his contract would not be renewed, Sainz delivered an extraordinary 2024 season, claiming victories in Australia and Mexico and proving himself as one of the most consistent drivers on the grid.
Eddie Jordan, speaking on the Formula For Success podcast, expressed disbelief over Ferrari’s choice, arguing that Sainz’s exceptional performance should have solidified his spot alongside Charles Leclerc.
Hamilton’s Move: A Risky Bet for Ferrari
Hamilton’s move to Ferrari, announced in early 2024, ends his illustrious association with Mercedes. Despite claiming wins in Britain and Belgium, Hamilton’s performance in 2024 was lackluster compared to his younger teammate George Russell. The British driver openly admitted he was “definitely not fast anymore” in qualifying, raising questions about his readiness to lead Ferrari into the future.
Jordan voiced concerns about Hamilton’s mindset, questioning whether Ferrari’s decision to bring him onboard was purely driven by his legacy rather than his current form. “When someone says, ‘I don’t think I’m fast anymore,’ that registers deeply,” Jordan remarked, hinting that Hamilton’s mental state could hinder his performance.
Ferrari’s Allure of Legacy and Marketing Power
David Coulthard, a former F1 driver, suggested that Ferrari’s decision may have been influenced by Hamilton’s unparalleled success and marketability. Hamilton’s signing briefly boosted Ferrari’s stock prices, highlighting the financial and promotional appeal of the seven-time champion.
Coulthard also noted that Hamilton’s departure from Mercedes offers the German team a graceful exit strategy. Mercedes is now set to welcome teenage prodigy Andrea Kimi Antonelli as Hamilton’s successor, a move that allows the team to transition into a new era without controversy.
Sainz’s Legacy at Ferrari
While Sainz prepares to join Williams for the 2025 season, his legacy at Ferrari remains intact. The Spaniard’s resilience and performances in 2024, despite the disappointment of his departure, have earned him widespread respect.
Ferrari now faces immense pressure to deliver a competitive car for Hamilton in 2025, as the team navigates the high-stakes gamble of replacing a rising star with a seasoned veteran.
The Verdict: Bold or Blunder?
As the F1 community debates Ferrari’s move, the spotlight will be on Hamilton’s ability to prove his critics wrong and Sainz’s quest to shine with his new team. One thing is certain—this decision will be remembered as one of the most talked-about moments in recent F1 history.
